Top eight blown wide open as Eels stun error-riddled Roosters

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

Top eight blown wide open as Eels stun error-riddled Roosters

Loading

Key posts

Pinned post from

Match report: Roosters dealt finals blow in error-riddled loss to Eels

By Adrian Proszenko

The Roosters have suffered a double blow in their finals push after losing halfback Sam Walker to a concussion in a shock loss to Parramatta.

Walker lasted just eight minutes before suffering a category-one concussion while attempting to tackle Eels forward Kelma Tuilagi.

Sam Walker is concussed while trying to tackle Kelma Tuilagi.

Sam Walker is concussed while trying to tackle Kelma Tuilagi.Credit: NRL Images

That knocked him out of his side’s 30-10 loss to the Eels and will also sideline him for Friday’s clash with the Storm.

The injury and the result add intrigue to the finals race, with Manly’s win against the Dolphins leaving four teams in contention for the final spot in the top eight.

The Roosters finish the regular season with two difficult assignments: Melbourne in Melbourne and then a showdown with arch-rivals South Sydney.

The Dolphins, Sea Eagles, or even the Tigers (they need some big wins and big Roosters losses) could still qualify for the post-season should the Tricolours slip up again.

Sam Walker is taken of for a HIA.

Sam Walker is taken of for a HIA.Credit: NRL Images

“I’m not happy tonight,” said Roosters coach Trent Robinson, who will pull Sandon Smith out of Sunday’s NSW Cup game with a view to the halfback replacing Walker.

“That’s really disappointing what happened. This is our life, this is what you do. You play a game, you get up, and you can’t repeat what you did last week, whether you won or lost.

“You have to recreate every match. We have to dust ourselves off and believe in what’s possible for us and our style of play and get it done.

“It’s really simple, there’s a purity in that, so game on next week.”

The Roosters have no shortage of halves on their books, with the likely arrival of Daly Cherry-Evans to add further to their depth. However, none of that helped at CommBank Stadium.

Walker’s spark and game management were sorely missed against an Eels side that ran harder, completed higher, and led from start to finish despite seemingly having less to play for.

In a game full of highlights, opposing wingers Josh Addo-Carr and Mark Nawaqanitawase provided the majority of them. “The Foxx” showed why he is still one of the NRL’s fastest flyers, scoring a length of the field intercept in scoring one of his two tries.

Nawaqanitawase, meanwhile, was producing plays that no other player is capable of. Whether it was an around-the-back try assist, a water polo-style pass to set up James Tedesco, or any number of try-saving efforts, “Marky Mark” made the unthinkable look easy.

However, his efforts were not nearly enough.

As the most senior half on the field, Mitchell Moses took control. Whether it was a spiral bomb that Tedesco couldn’t get a hand to or the grubber that he grounded to seal the result, the Parramatta captain was a class above.

With Daniel Tupou missing with a concussion, replacement winger Junior Tupou was successfully targeted all night.

Moses wasn’t the only Eel with the golden boot. Walker found Addo-Carr with the second kick in a sequence, but even better was to come.

The ball was kicked three times before Jordan Semrani dived on the loose ball to score the first of his two tries. Beware the third kick.

The finals are out of reach in Jason Ryles’ first year, but he hasn’t struggled to motivate his troops at the back end of the season.

“I find no matter what time of year it is, our training schedule and how we prepare is very similar,” Ryles said.

“Regardless of what round it is, we’ll continue to prepare the way we do. Everything has an element of fight and effort in it in regards to what the game looks like. I think we’ve seen that tonight … we’re getting ready to put the badge on and win.”

The win ensures there is no world in which Parramatta can earn the wooden spoon. The fate of the Roosters, whose for-and-against copped a hammering, is also unclear.

Latest posts

Hasler rages after loss to Warriors

Stats after 80 minutes

Eels stun error-riddled Roosters

That’s full-time at CommBank Stadium, where the Eels have ended the Roosters winning streak with a 30-10 victory in Parramatta.

It was a horrific night for the Tricolours, after they lost Sam Walker in the opening 10 minutes when he was concussed while trying to make a tackle on Kelma Tuilagi.

But the Eels were the better team, with Joash Papalii, Isaiah Iongi, Ryley Smith and Mitch Moses just a handful of the players who rose to the occasion for their team.

The Roosters, on the other hand, were horrific. At full-time their completion rate was 57 per cent, and now they are no guarantee of playing finals football, with the Dolphins and Sea Eagles just one win behind them on the ladder.

The Eels celebrate.

The Eels celebrate.Credit: Getty Images

Advertisement

Samrani gets a double from Tupou error

There aren’t many minutes left in this match, but another Roosters error leads to an Eels try.

It’s a completely unnecessary error too, as Junior Tupou attempts an offload to James Tedesco in the in-goal.

Tedesco isn’t expecting it at all, and when the ball goes to ground, Jordan Samrani gets a hand to it to score his second try of the night.

Eels 30, Roosters 10 with two minutes to go

Roosters have worst completion rate of any team in 2025

With five minutes to go, things continue to not click for the Roosters.

Their error count is at 17 now, and their completion rate is at 58 per cent – that’s the worst completion rate of any team in the 2025 season...yikes.

The inevitable loss tonight makes the competition very interesting, with the Roosters, Dolphins, Sea Eagles and even Wests Tigers now a chance of wrapping up the final spot in the 2025 finals.

Eels 26, Roosters 10 with five minutes to go

Eels score ridiculous team try

It’s official, CommBank Stadium has descended into madness.

There’s an over-the-head backwards pass from Zac Lomax, a soccer kick from Charlie Guymer, and a last-minute grounding from Jordan Samrani to secure the Eels fifth try of the night.

Somehow there wasn’t a knock-on, somehow the Roosters couldn’t clean-up the ball, and somehow the Eels are on track to upset the Tricolours tonight.

Eels 26, Roosters 10 with 15 minutes to go

Advertisement

Eels continue to impress

Very impressive from Parramatta so far.

With Dylan Walker off, Mitchell Moses has taken control of this. The other Eel who has really impressed me is Ryley Smith. The arrival of Tallyn Da Silva, a contender for the starting hooker spot, has elevated Smith’s game. Those two will provide a huge threat from dummy half in the years to come.

That piece of Mark Nawaqanitawase brilliance has given the Roosters hope.

Stunning pass from Nawaqanitawase keeps Roosters hopes alive

Is there anything Mark Nawaqanitawase can’t do?

A round-the-back flick bass from Nawaqanitawase on the right edge keeps the ball alive, and makes its way into the hands of Robert Toia who scores.

That’s an absolutely freakish play from the Roosters winger. Crazy scenes.

Hugo Savala adds the extras and it’s a 10-point game. Don’t count the Roosters out just yet.

Eels 20, Roosters 10 with 20 minutes to go

Moses scores skilful individual try

The Eels make the Roosters pay following that Lindsay Collins error.

Mitch Moses decides to take things into his own hands 10 metres from the Roosters line, as he puts in a grubber, chases the ball and scores.

Zac Lomax converts from in front and the Eels surge to a 16-point lead.

Eels 20, Roosters 4 with 27 minutes to go

Most Viewed in Sport

Loading